In its propaganda, the Chinese Communist Party does
not deny the value of "democracy", but it insists that
democracy in China can be only "socialist democracy with
Chinese characteristics". The most essential nature of
such "democracy" is that it is under the single-party
system and it excludes multi-party politics and
competitive elections. In recent years, "Chinese
democracy" has won more support because of achievements
the party has made in developing economy. This raises a
question: does this "efficient" authoritarian political
system in China, even if it is not democratic, deserve
applause because it can facilitate economic development?
The party also insists that it is "democratic". But, is
the party's theory of "democracy" compatible with
western democracy? Since 1998, the party has organized
some political reforms, such as "direct elections" for
township executives, "direct elections" for township
party secretaries, township party congress reform and
"deliberative democracy" experiments, while maintaining
single-party politics. In the party's propaganda, some
of these reforms have become party achievements in
improving "socialist democracy with Chinese
characteristics". In addition to these four kinds of
party-organized reforms, another "reform" originated
from the grassroots, the participation of independent
candidates in a few local people's congress elections.
This book examines these five local political reforms.
It demonstrates that the four reforms instigated and
organized by the party were tightly controlled and
manipulated by the party. Although some reform measures
may possibly liberalize parts of China's political
mechanism, it is highly unlikely that the four reforms
will eventually lead to political democratization in
China. In the fifth "reform", which was motivated from
outside the bureaucratic system, the party took drastic
measures to repress the political participation of
grassroots power. As a result, nearly all independent
candidates in the local people's congress elections
failed in their attempts to gain office. The prospects
for this "reform" are also poor. The book argues that
all five reforms have failed and that none will lead to
China's democratization in the near future. The book
concludes that the party's authoritarian regime in China
is by nature anti-democratic and that so-called
"socialist democracy with Chinese characteristics" is
not democratic.
|
|