The environment has long been the undisputed
territory of the political Left, which casts
international capitalism, consumerism, and the
over-exploitation of natural resources as the principle
threats to the planet, and sees top-down interventions
as the most effective solution. In How to Think
Seriously About the Planet, Roger Scruton rejects this
view and offers a fresh approach to tackling the most
important political problem of our time. The
environmental movement, he contends, is philosophically
confused and has unrealistic agendas. Its sights are
directed at the largescale events and the confrontation
between international politics and multinational
business. But Scruton argues that no large-scale
environmental project, however well-intentioned, will
succeed if it is not rooted in small-scale practical
reasoning. Seeing things on a large scale promotes
top-down solutions, managed by unaccountable
bureaucracies that fail to assess local conditions and
are rife with unintended consequences. Scruton argues
for the greater efficacy of local initiatives over
global schemes, civil association over political
activism, and small-scale institutions of friendship
over regulatory hyper-vigilance. And he suggests that
conservatism is far better suited to solving
environmental problems than either liberalism or
socialism. Rather than entrusting the environment to
unwieldy NGOs and international committees, we must
assume personal responsibility and foster local control.
People must be empowered to take charge of their
environment, to care for it as they would a home, and to
involve themselves through the kind of local
associations that have been the traditional goal of
conservative politics. Our common future is by no means
assured, but as Roger Scruton clearly demonstrates in
this important book, there is a path that can ensure the
future safety of our planet and our species. |
|