| CD 1 |
| 1. Once in Royal David's City |
| 2. Ding Dong! Merrily on High (French) |
| 3. O Come, All Ye Faithful |
| 4. The Holly and the Ivy (English) |
| 5. Hark! The Herald Angels Sing |
| 6. Silent Night |
| 7. While Shepherds Watched Their Flocks by Night (Este's Psaler, 1592) |
| 8. In Bleak Midwinter |
| 9. God Rest You Merry, Gentlemen (English, West Country) |
| 10. The Lamb |
| 11. Angels, From the Realms of Glory (French) |
| 12. Adam Lay Ybounden |
| 13. The Three Kings |
| 14. I Saw a Maiden (English, Basque) |
| 15. Whence Is That Goodly Fragrance Flowing? (French) |
| 16. Quem Pastores Laudavere (German) |
| 17. Tomorrow Shall Be My Dancing Day (English) |
| 18. A Maiden Most Gentle (French) |
| 19. A Spotless Rose |
| 20. Sans Day Carol (Cornish) |
| 21. I Wonder as I Wander |
| 22. The Cherry Tree Carol (English) |
| 23. I Sing of a Maiden |
| 24. Gabriel's Message (Basque) |
| 25. Personent Hodie (Piae Cantiones, 1582) (German) |
| CD 2 |
| 1. The First Nowell (English) |
| 2. In Dulci Jubilo (German) |
| 3. O Little Town of Bethlehem (English) |
| 4. I Saw Three Ships (English) |
| 5. It Came Upon the Midnight Clear (English) |
| 6. Away in a Manger |
| 7. Sussex Carol (English) |
| 8. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel (French) |
| 9. Myn Lyking |
| 10. Jesus Christ the Apple Tree |
| 11. All My Heart This Night Rejoices |
| 12. Dormi, Jesu |
| 13. Riu, Riu, Chiu |
| 14. O Jesulein Süss (O Little One Sweet) (German) (Schemelli's Gesangbuch, |
| 15. The Shepherd's Cradle Song (German, Bohemian) |
| 16. How Far Is It to Bethlehem? (English) |
| 17. The Truth from Above (English) |
| 18. Up! Good Christen Folk and (Piae Cantiones) |
| 19. Remember, O Thou Man |
| 20. Quittez, Pasteurs (French) |
| 21. The Lord at First Did Adam Make (English) |
| 22. The Infant King (Basque) |
| 23. A Child Is Born in Bethlehem |
| 24. And All in the Morning (English) |
| 25. Of the Father's Heart Begotten (Piae Cantiones) |
| 26. Organ Voluntary: In Dulci Jubilo, BWV 729 |
